Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Shining a Light on Newtown; A Different Perspective

Almost every blogger did a post about Newtown; every blogger except me. It certainly wasn't because I wasn't sorrowful and affected like the rest of the US, but I just wasn't sure where to start. While the nation grieved, I thought about myself and my own family. It was a selfish thing, but let me explain. You see, my family was affected by a school shooting back before school shootings were all the rage, literally.

My uncle Carl's sister-in-law, Deanna McDavid, was shot in the head, killed by one of her students as the other students watched in utter disbelief. I'm sure unless you are related to me or you happened to be from the area, you didn't even know about this incident. It was big news, being one of the first school shootings, but there was no immediate media hype like today, no instant Internet blitz to alert the world that my family bubble had been burst.

It happened in the sleepy little town where I visited my dad's family on a regular basis over my forty-three years; my grandma, two aunts, and two uncles, my cousins, and extended families. Even though Deanna was on my uncle's wife's side of the family, I spent time with them growing up. Deanna's kids were my cousin's age and I spent a lot of time with my aunt Betty (Deanna's sister) and uncle Carl and I have been blessed to know them. They are outgoing, spirited, and kind. They have endured unspeakable tragedy.

When I heard about the shooting at Newtown, I suppose it hit me in a different way than most. Frankly, I found myself less upset than most and if you know me, that would surprise you. I am easy to cry. Yes, it was tragic. The sheer number involved and the fact that they were children was heartbreaking, but the truth is that I had "been there, done that" nearly twenty years ago. That sounds terrible, but if you have trouble wondering why people react in certain ways to certain things, perhaps this article will shed some light for you.

Am I hardened? Not necessarily. I remember being very affected by Columbine and the Virginia Tech shootings. I vividly remember watching TV coverage of Virginia Tech and bawling like a baby. I remember choking back tears as I told my boyfriend's young son about Columbine and then soaking up the media details, trying to understand.

Most people want to understand why and how someone could do such a thing. Now, years later, there are plenty of articles on the Internet about the shooting at East Carter High School where my aunt's sister and a custodian were killed. One article I read stated that he didn't have a beef with Deanna, but he wanted to kill two random people so that he would be eligible for the death penalty. His logic didn't work. He remains in jail to this day.

Did you know there have been 386 school shootings since 1992? Here's a website with statistics Stop The Shootings and I must be honest, I had no idea there were that many. Not all involved fatalities. Does this make them any less impactful?

No, the incidents were tragic in each case, I'm sure. Not all involved children or teachers being shot. Not all involved a troubled teen saying to one of my family members, "Shut up, bitch," and then carrying out his own version of a death sentence on her just one day before her 49th birthday.

As a writer, this story is personal for me in more ways than one. Deanna was an English teacher. Prior to killing her, Gary Scott Pennington had turned in writing assignments with content that concerned her and she had given him a C grade which he thought might affect his college prospects. His killing method was eerily based on Stephen King's novel (published under a pseudonym), Rage, about a student who kills his teacher in front of students -- in Kentucky, no less. Coincidence? It's debatable. The things Gary Scott Pennington said in his shooting were eerily similar, but in life, I've had eerie coincidences more than a few times. There is reporting to say that he read it before the killings and reporting to say that he didn't.

Can writing influence action among a readership? Certainly! This would not be the first time King's story was connected to a school shooting, nor would it be the last. Do I blame Stephen King for Deanna's murder? No way. That would be stupid. I used to be a huge Stephen King fan. I am no killer, nor do I use it as a springboard for my own twisted mind, but some do.

I don't blame his writing as a tool of destruction any more than I blame the gun. It is the person behind it who remains ultimately responsible. Had it not been a story idea or an availability of guns, he would have found another way to express his mental state of frustration. Perhaps a bomb or a knife would have been the weapon of choice. He would have found some thing, some way, some awful end to make his point stick in the collective mind.

Here are a few articles about the crime.
People Magazine: Reading, Writing and Murder
US News: The Tragedy in Room 108 (Thank you, Jerry Buckley, for allowing me to get to know her even better through your great writing).

I didn't watch much coverage on Newtown and the tragedy at Sandy Hook. I give the victims the honor they deserve, lives lost too soon, but I refuse to let fear and depression grip me and keep me in its hold where my life is concerned. I just won't do it. Why? I've wasted too much time with that sort of focus in the past and it did me no good. Rather, it was detrimental. I smile and laugh, not out of insensitivity and denial, but in the face of the devil. He won't have me. He can't have me... unless I allow it.

After the most recent school shooting tragedy at Sandy Hook, I posted on a humor thread about the appropriateness of using humor again after tragedy and got the following response from a man who put things into a different perspective when he replied:

" for me, I learned this news just 10 minutes back from Humor Writers! I am exactly on the opposite side of the globe... partly, the result of not being able to afford to live in the U.S. any longer, and met no one who told me this. I would have had to meet an American, no Cambodian would consider this to be news. Now when 350 people died here because of the collapse of a bridge, that was news. I think that gives a sense of perspective. We feel the loss of those close to us, but tragedy from a distance does not touch us. ???"

Wow, he is so right! It really hit me, that particular sentence, "no Cambodian would consider this to be news." It's all about what we're exposed to on a regular basis. Is the school shooting more tragic than genocide? Deaths in hurricane Katrina? Lives lost when the Titanic went down?

These children killed at Sandy Hook are a sad reminder that tragedy happens and our children are not safe. However, it did not make me hug my children tighter, tell them I love them more, or get up in arms about gun control. It simply reminded me that every day is a quiet blessing and if you are treating them any differently than you did the day before, you are doing them a disservice.

You should be hugging them every day as though today could be the last. I've already learned in life that the tragedy can be you, your neighbor, your cousin, your friend, or your child. It can happen in a thousand different ways. Illness, accidents, tragic circumstances or whatever, it can all be over in the blink of an eye. So do we cease to blink? No, we learn to keep one eye open and see more clearly between blinks, that's all.

As I engaged in my 2012 Christmas rituals with my husband and children yesterday, my thoughts drifted to the families and community of Newtown and I realized how blessed I am. I am between tragedies. Will they happen again in my lifetime? You can be sure of it. Am I better prepared? Never. But I am gaining new perspectives throughout my years and that helps me to see things in different light. In the darkest days, I sometimes need that light.

I choose to use that light to celebrate the lives of those lost and not mourn for too long. Those I have loved and lost would never want to see me grieve long-term. It's so destructive. Long-term grief and anger eat away the very fibers of faith, love, and happiness and pull your focus to the dark side. I've lost much in my lifetime and have only begun to hint at it in my writing. I've learned much about keeping a light on in the process.

My light burns for you tonight, your little ones, your mothers and fathers, your friends, and even your enemies. Remember, you can be a Stephen King kind of Shining, or a Shining light of your own design. The choice is up to you. Please share how you shine in the light of this tragedy in your unique way. Have you instilled hope in your children? Comforted a friend? Helped someone cope with it all? I'd like to hear from you.


  1. I'm not sure there is A right way to react to these kind of tragedies. I remember when John Lennon was murdered, I was shocked and saddened, but when John Bonham (Led Zeppelin) OD'd a few months later, I was absolutely emotionally trashed. Not because I admired JB more than JL, that was just how it "hit" me at the time.

    I am learning, now, to honor my feelings, whatever they are, even if they aren't exactly what others are feeling or reacting, and, indeed, to make the most of every day.

  2. Thank you for your perspective...I feel very much the same way in regards to understanding how to feel the pain in a way that is productive, if that makes any sense at all. The Newtown incident hit closer to home for me because I am from there...grew up there and graduated from Newtown High School. I have friends who still live and/or work there, some as teachers and some as first responders. That said, I haven't lived there in 30 years. It's all about understanding the difference between clean and dirty pain.

  3. Hi Cindy - I have said over again that you are a gifted humor writer, however, I cannot emphasize enough how gifted you are when also dealing with a serious topic. Thank you for sharing your point of view. Tragedies strike us all quite differently. For me, it took me back a few months ago to when I instinctively pushed my daughter out of the way of an oncoming car (which turned out not to be a car at all) and it made me think of how parents will do anything to protect their children. I tell Melissa and Bob I love them every single day, several times a day for the reasons you describe, because you never know... xoxo - Lisa

  4. Thank you for these words.. love you Cin - Ginny
    Those I have loved and lost would never want to see me grieve long-term. It's so destructive. Long-term grief and anger eat away the very fibers of faith, love, and happiness and pull your focus to the dark side

  5. What a beautifully written post, Cindy. I'm sorry for your loss of your Aunt. That must have been devastating. I have responded to the Newtown tragedy in a much more basic way of anger and disbelief. I am furious about the gun laws. I am furious about the lack of control. I remember when there was a shooting in Canada at the University in Quebec and I was a University student at the time. I was so touched and horrified by the event. I couldn't come to terms with it. Of course, there have been many more since. The thing that bothers me the most is my ability to forget about it as though it never happened. I hope we don't forget about this and something is done about the use of that particular (30 bullets) firearm. Still, your perspective is very common sense and thank you for your post.

  6. Thanks for the comment, Lisa. I wasn't sure how this piece would go over. You never know when you are going to offend someone when you are a writer!

  7. Lisa, that comment is very important. I want to write serious work as well someday, but have been unsure as to how I come across. So far, so good. I get decent feedback either way, from wonderfully intelligent women. I value the feedback from my readership so much! Thank you.

  8. Karen, I imagine I would feel differently if I had been from Newtown. It's all about the exposure we have in life and the experiences that mold us. Clean and dirty pain is a very perceptive thing. You have talked about it well in your writing. I can tell that you heal every day from your past wounds. I like that about you! :0)

  9. I admit I cried a few times over the incident in Newtown. I'm a former teacher and I have a daughter in kindergarten. When I picked my daughter up from school and saw the police officer watching all the parents, I wanted to hug him. Instead I thanked him for being there. I hate that we can't feel safe sending our children to school. I hate that there are people who would take innocent lives. But we can't stop living. I don't know what the answer is.

  10. I wrote about surviving tragedy on my blog this week and since I wanted to keep it somewhat light I left out this shooting, figuring everyone knows more than they probably wanted to know about it anyway. Thanks for being the brave one and writing this post. Your right Cindy, everyday we have is a blessing. Hope you have a Happy New Year.

  11. Becky Green AaronsonJanuary 2, 2013 at 12:05 PM

    Cindy, I have to say I had a polar opposite reaction to the Sandy Hook massacre. Every shooting has left me reeling over the years but this one (along with the Portland shooting a few days before and the volunteer firefighters being gunned down a few days later in NY), has finally propelled me into action. I can no longer take the gun insanity in our country--at least not without trying to do something about it. I definitely agree that we can't stop living. For me, the way I can do that is by rising up and saying, "Enough is enough." The horror of your relative's murder just reiterates it to me. I'm so sorry for your family's loss. I'm glad you are shining a light on this tragedy in your own way, though. We all process things differently, and no one way is right.

  12. That is so intuitive of you to recognize that no one way to process is right. I appreciate everyone's reaction and words about it. My own just happened to differ from most this time and I found that interesting enough to talk about. I love humor, but when I write, my fingertips bleed truth whether it's understood or not. I intended for the post to be about fear, but it tuned into something a little different in the end.

  13. Thank you, Eve... best wishes to you, too. I almost didn't write about it, but something kept pushing me. Turns out someone messaged me privately and something I said here did help them heal from a tragic death, so it was meant to be, I guess.

  14. There is no answer. I feel bad for those who keep searching for the answers in the face of tragedy. The enemy beats us in this way, I think. It keeps our focus on the wrong things and keeps us confused and angry instead of hopeful, positive, and active. I've been through so much in my life, it has "seasoned" me in a strange way, I must admit.

  15. I don't think there are answers. Not ones I'd understand anyway. I feel for the people affected, but I won't waste time wondering how someone could do something like this. That I know I've never understand.

  16. I really liked your take on this. Thank you for sharing

  17. Thanks for stopping in for a read, Camille!

  18. Hello, just wanted to say, I loved this article. It was practical.
    Keep on posting!

    my weblog ...

  19. Can you tell us more about this? I'd love to find out more details.

    Also visit my webpage ... Pirater Un compte facebook

  20. I know this web site offers quality based content and other information, is
    there any other site which presents these information in quality?

    my website www.Youtube.Com

  21. Excellent article! We will be linking to this great article on our site.
    Keep up the great writing.

    Look into my site - Microsoft Office Gratuit

  22. Ridiculous quest there. What occurred after? Take care!

    my web-site - pirater un Compte facebook

  23. Great blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers?
    I'm hoping to start my own site soon but I'm a little lost on everything.
    Would you suggest starting with a free platform like Wordpress or
    go for a paid option? There are so many options out there that I'm completely confused .. Any tips? Thanks!

    Look at my blog post: Psn Code Generator

  24. Spot on with this write-up, I truly believe that this amazing site
    needs a lot more attention. I'll probably be back again to see more, thanks for the information!

    Here is my blog - dragon city hack

  25. hey there and thank you for your info – I have definitely picked up anything new
    from right here. I did however expertise some technical issues using
    this web site, as I experienced to reload the website a lot
    of times previous to I could get it to load correctly.
    I had been wondering if your hosting is OK?
    Not that I am complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement
    in google and can damage your quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords.
    Anyway I'm adding this RSS to my email and can look out for a lot more of your respective exciting content. Make sure you update this again very soon.

    Here is my web blog - Generateur de Code PSN

  26. magnificent publish, very informative. I wonder why the opposite experts of
    this sector don't notice this. You should continue your writing. I'm confident, you have a great
    readers' base already!

    Feel free to surf to my homepage - psn code generator

  27. Fastidious replies in return of this question with genuine arguments and
    telling everything concerning that.

    My homepage ... code Psn Gratuit